• Insurance
  • Lead Generation
  • Compliance

Leads for Health Insurance: Buy, Generate or Both

Josh Pocock

8 min read

Leads for health insurance come from two places: vendors who sell quote requests, and campaigns you run yourself. Most agencies that write a lot of under-65 and ACA business use both, and the calendar decides the mix. Demand piles into open enrollment, so that is when bought leads cost the most and when your own campaigns and your existing book earn the most.

Buy real-time leads to fill open enrollment, use aged leads only with a dialing plan, and build your own campaigns and renewal list so every year starts with people who already know you. Whatever the source, every lead needs consent that covers your agency and a reply within minutes.

Below is the open enrollment calendar, how bought health insurance leads are priced, the consent rules that apply to calls and texts, and how to generate your own.

The health insurance lead calendar

Health insurance lead generation runs on one window. On HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for 2027 plans starts November 1 and ends January 15. Plans picked by December 15 start January 1, and enrollments from December 16 to January 15 start February 1 (HealthCare.gov). After January 15, people can only enroll or change plans if they qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, such as a move, a new baby or losing other coverage. If your state runs its own marketplace, check its dates too.

WindowWhat the lead looks likeWhere to put your effort
September and OctoberEarly shoppers, renewal questionsContact your existing book, warm up your ad accounts, build pages
November 1 to December 15Peak demand, January 1 start datesReal-time leads, search ads, fastest follow-up of the year
December 16 to January 15Late shoppers, February 1 start datesKeep the campaigns on, chase every unbooked quote
February to OctoberSpecial Enrollment Period shoppersLife event campaigns, referrals, aged lead tests

Buying health insurance leads: real-time, exclusive and aged

Health insurance leads for agents are sold the same four ways as other insurance leads: shared, exclusive, live transfer and aged. LeadGen Economy's insurance benchmarks (2025 prices, published November 2025) list ACA and under-65 health leads at:

Lead typeOff-seasonOpen enrollment
Shared$25 to $50$40 to $80
Exclusive$50 to $100$60 to $150
Live transfer$65 to $125$80 to $175
Aged (30 to 90 days)$8 to $20$10 to $30

The same report says open enrollment "concentrates 60-70% of annual health insurance lead demand" and that prices rise 30% to 50% above baseline at the December peak. These are figures from a lead-industry publisher, so treat them as market ranges, not quotes.

Real-time leads arrive seconds after the shopper submits a form. Shared ones go to several agencies at once, so the first agent to call usually gets the conversation. That makes response time the biggest lever on what a shared lead really costs.

Aged leads are resold after 30, 60 or 90 days. LeadGen Economy says they typically price at 5% to 20% of fresh lead costs. They work for agents with a patient, multi-day text and call plan, and they work best in the off-season, when a shopper who did not buy in December may have had a qualifying life event since.

Our guides to exclusive vs shared leads and how much insurance leads cost go deeper on buyer counts, contact rates and the cost per policy math.

Health insurance leads carry more rules than most, because both the FCC and CMS have something to say.

  • Consent for autodialed, AI and prerecorded calls. Telemarketing calls to a cell phone using an autodialer or an artificial or prerecorded voice need the called person's prior express written consent (47 CFR 64.1200). The FCC has ruled that AI-generated voices count as artificial voices under the TCPA (FCC 24-17).
  • The one-to-one consent rule is gone. The FCC's 2023 rule, which would have required consent naming a single seller, was struck down by the Eleventh Circuit in January 2025 (Morrison Foerster summary). The FCC then reinstated the prior consent definition in a rule effective August 29, 2025 (Federal Register). Consent that clearly names your agency is still the cleanest record to keep when you buy leads.
  • Opt-outs. A person can revoke consent "by using any reasonable method", and you must honor it within 10 business days. Do-not-call requests must be kept for 5 years, and telemarketing calls can only go out between 8 a.m. and 9 p.m. in the called person's time zone (47 CFR 64.1200).
  • Marketplace consent. Agents and brokers helping consumers through the federal marketplace must "obtain and document the receipt of consent" from the consumer, including the scope, purpose and duration of that consent, and keep the record for at least 10 years (45 CFR 155.220).
  • Medicare is a separate rulebook. If you also sell Medicare Advantage, CMS requires the third-party marketing disclaimer to be "verbally conveyed during sales calls prior to the discussion of any benefits" (42 CFR 422.2267).

Ask every vendor for the consent language on the form, a timestamp and the page the shopper submitted it on, and keep those records with the lead.

How to generate your own health insurance leads

Bought leads fill a busy November. Your own leads keep the other ten months full, and nobody else is calling them.

Google search ads

People typing "health insurance quotes" or "ACA plans in [state]" are ready to talk. Google requires its own certification to advertise health and medical insurance in the US, and advertisers must be certified with G2 first. Ads only for dental, vision or travel cover are not restricted (Google). LocaliQ's 2026 search benchmarks put the finance and insurance average at $3.39 a click and $74.44 a lead, a category that also includes banks and lenders (LocaliQ). See Google Ads for insurance agents.

Facebook and Instagram ads

Meta reaches self-employed people, early retirees and young families before they search. Meta says ads for insurance services "must be targeted to people 18 years or older" and that advertisers may need to verify their identity and show they are licensed (Meta). Run one offer per campaign, such as a plan review before open enrollment. Our playbook for Facebook ads for insurance agents covers the creative and the form.

Your website and Google Business Profile

A page for each county or city you serve, one for open enrollment dates and one for Special Enrollment Period life events will collect searches all year. A Google Business Profile is free (Google) and puts your agency in local results. Insurance agency SEO covers the build.

Your book of business

Every client you enrolled last year is a renewal conversation this fall, and every one of them knows someone who is self-employed or between jobs. Contact clients who opted in from September, before the vendors' ads start. Lapsed clients and old quote requests are worth a structured database reactivation campaign.

Buy, generate or both: a simple plan

Your situationPlan
New agent, no bookReal-time shared leads in open enrollment, called within a minute; build a referral habit from day one
Established agency, small teamExclusive leads at the peak, your own search ads all year, renewal campaign from September
Agency with call capacity to spareAged leads in the off-season with a multi-day plan, your own Meta campaigns for Special Enrollment Period life events
Agency writing health and MedicareSeparate campaigns, scripts and consent records for each, with the CMS disclaimer built into Medicare calls

What follow-up has to do in open enrollment

Every source above produces leads that go cold in minutes. A shopper who fills in three forms on a Sunday night is talking to whoever answers first.

A first reply for a health insurance quote request might look like this:

AI: Hi Dana, this is the AI assistant for Lakeview Benefits Group. You asked about health coverage for 2027. Is it just you, or are you covering family too?

Dana: Me and my two kids.

AI: Thanks. One of our licensed agents can walk you through the plans in your area. I can't give plan advice or prices myself, but I can book you a call. Does tomorrow at 10 or 2 work?

The agent says it is an AI assistant, asks one question at a time and books the licensed agent. It never recommends a plan, quotes a premium or promises coverage. Our guide to insurance lead follow-up has the full cadence and scripts.

FAQ

How do I get leads for health insurance?

Buy real-time leads during open enrollment, run your own Google and Meta campaigns, build local pages and a Google Business Profile, and work your existing book for renewals and referrals. Most agencies use a mix and shift it with the calendar.

What are ACA leads?

ACA leads are people asking about individual or family plans sold on the marketplace. On HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for 2027 plans runs November 1 to January 15, so ACA lead demand peaks then.

Are aged health insurance leads worth it?

They can be, with a multi-day plan and enough dialing capacity. LeadGen Economy says aged leads typically cost 5% to 20% of fresh ones. They work best in the off-season, when some shoppers now qualify for a Special Enrollment Period.

Yes. Autodialed, AI voice and prerecorded telemarketing calls to cell phones need prior express written consent under 47 CFR 64.1200, and marketplace agents must document consumer consent under 45 CFR 155.220.

Can I run Google ads for health insurance?

Yes, after Google certifies you. Google requires G2 certification first, then its own health insurance certification, and ACA keywords need an extra certificate (Google).

Fill open enrollment and the other ten months

We run health insurance campaigns on Google and Meta and answer every opted-in quote request in under 2 seconds, then book the call with your licensed agents. We have served 400+ clients since 2019 and get most clients live in 2 to 3 weeks. See lead generation for insurance agents, or Book a Stride Scaling Call.

Done for you

Want this running in your business?

We build and run AI that answers, follows up and books calls, all reporting into one CRM. Most clients are live in 2 to 3 weeks.

Keep reading

    • Insurance
    • Lead Generation

    8 min read

    Free Leads for Life Insurance: Where Agents Find Them

    Free leads for life insurance agents: your book, referrals, life events, local events, Google Business Profile and content, plus when it pays to buy leads.

    Read post
    • Insurance
    • Lead Generation

    8 min read

    Leads for Car Insurance: A Guide for P&C Agents

    Leads for car insurance agents: quote-intent buyers, speed to call, home and auto bundles, commercial leads, renewal reactivation and the consent rules.

    Read post
    • Insurance
    • Lead Generation

    7 min read

    How Much Do Insurance Leads Cost?

    How much do insurance leads cost: shared, exclusive, live transfer and aged prices for auto, home, life, final expense and Medicare, and the cost per policy.

    Read post