• SEO
  • Local SEO
  • Lead Generation

How to Choose an SEO Company for a Small Business

Josh Pocock

8 min read

The right SEO company for a small business builds pages that win the searches your customers make, fixes what holds your site back, and shows you the calls and forms that work brings in. The wrong one sends a monthly ranking report and little else. Both look the same on a sales call.

Choose an SEO company for a small business on what it will deliver each month in writing, who owns the accounts and content, how it reports leads rather than rankings, and what the contract lets you do if the work is not delivered. Walk away from anyone who guarantees a ranking.

Below is what a small business SEO package should include, the questions to ask, the red flags, the contract terms that protect you and a scorecard you can copy. We are one of the SEO companies you might compare, and we say where we fit at the end.

What a small business SEO package should include

Whatever it is called, a package for a local service business should cover these six things. If a quote leaves one out, ask why.

PartWhat it meansWhat you should see
ResearchThe searches that bring in revenue in your area, and who ranks for them nowA list of target searches by service and town, agreed with you
Technical fixesSpeed, indexing, site structure and schemaAn audit, then a list of fixes shipped
Service and location pagesA page for each service, and for each town you want work fromNew or improved pages every month, written for your trade
Google Business ProfileCategories, services, photos, posts and reviewsRegular updates to the profile that shows in the map results
Citations and reviewsConsistent business details across directories, and a steady flow of reviewsA citation cleanup and a review request process
ReportingWhat changed, and what it brought inCalls and forms from organic search, not only rankings

The cheapest packages tend to drop the pages and keep the report. The pages are where most of the ranking comes from for a local business, so that is the line to check first. How much SEO costs for a small business shows what each pricing model usually buys and the survey ranges. If you would rather do the work yourself, local SEO for small businesses is the step-by-step checklist.

Ten questions to ask an SEO company

Google publishes its own list of questions to ask an SEO, including "Can you show me examples of your previous work and share some success stories?" and "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?" (Google Search Central). These ten go further for a small service business:

  1. What will you deliver each month? Pages, fixes, profile updates. In numbers, in writing.
  2. Which searches will you target first, and why those? A good answer names services and towns that pay, not the biggest search volumes.
  3. Who writes the pages, and how do they learn my business? You want someone who asks about your jobs, prices and service area.
  4. What is your experience in my industry and my city? Google lists both questions too.
  5. How do you report results? Look for calls and forms from organic search, tracked to the page that earned them.
  6. Do I own the website, the content and the accounts? Your Google Business Profile, Search Console and analytics should be in your name.
  7. What access do you need? Google advises that you "only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)" when you first engage an SEO (Google Search Central).
  8. Do you follow Google Search Essentials? Google suggests asking this directly.
  9. Who will I talk to, and how often? A named person and a set meeting, not a ticket queue.
  10. What happens if I cancel? You should keep every page, every account and the history.

Red flags

  • A ranking guarantee. Google says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" and warns "Beware of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings" (Google Search Central).
  • Cold outreach that opens with a problem on your site. Google says to "Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue."
  • Link schemes. Google says to avoid "SEOs that talk about link popularity schemes or submitting your site to thousands of search engines."
  • "Google approved" tools. Google says to "Be wary of tools that claim to be 'acceptable' or 'approved' by Google Search."
  • A price with no deliverables. If you cannot list what you get each month, you cannot check it.
  • Accounts in the agency's name. If your profile or site sits in their account, you are hard to fire them from.
  • Rankings for phrases nobody searches. A report full of page one rankings for terms with no volume is not a result.

Contract terms that protect you

  • Ownership. You own the site, the content, the Google Business Profile, Search Console and analytics, during and after the contract.
  • Scope. The monthly deliverables are listed in the agreement, not only in the proposal.
  • Term and notice. A clear minimum term and notice period. SEO takes months, so a minimum term is reasonable. One with no way out if the deliverables are not met is not.
  • Reporting. A monthly report with calls and forms from organic search, plus the work shipped that month.
  • Exit. What you receive on the last day: logins, content files and a list of everything changed on your site.

Best SEO company for a small business: local, national or freelancer?

There is no single best SEO company for every small business. The best one for you is the one that does the six parts above well for businesses like yours, and reports leads. Each type has trade-offs:

TypeUsually good atWatch for
FreelancerLower cost, direct contactCapacity, and gaps in skills like technical fixes or writing
Local agencyKnowing your market, meeting in personWhether they actually build pages or mainly sell listings
Specialist agency for your industryKnowing your services, buyers and competitorsWhether they also work for your direct competitors
Agency that runs SEO with ads and follow-upOne report across channels, leads answered fastMaking sure SEO gets real attention next to paid ads

Affordable SEO services for small business: what to expect

Affordable should mean a smaller scope done properly, not the full scope done badly. If the budget is tight:

  1. Fix the foundation first: Google Business Profile, a fast site and correct business details everywhere.
  2. Build pages for your best service in your main town before you spread across every town.
  3. Ask for reviews from every happy customer and reply to them.
  4. Add pages and towns as calls come in and the budget grows.

A one-page scorecard

CheckWhat a good answer looks likeYes / No
Monthly deliverablesWritten, in numbers
Target searchesServices and towns that bring revenue
ContentWritten for your trade, edited by people
ReportingCalls and forms from organic search
OwnershipSite, content and accounts in your name
AccessRead access to Search Console to start
GuaranteesNone on rankings
ContractClear term, notice and exit
ContactA named person and a set meeting
ExperienceYour industry and your kind of market

Where Executive Stride fits

We are one option. Executive Stride runs SEO for local service businesses: keyword and competitor research, a technical audit and fixes, service and location pages written with AI and edited by people, Google Business Profile optimization, and a monthly report that ties rankings to leads. We do not guarantee rankings, because Google decides them. We commit to the work and show it every month.

What we add is what happens after the ranking. Organic leads land in the same CRM as paid leads, and our AI appointment setters reply to every opted-in lead in under 2 seconds and book the job. Our playbooks for HVAC SEO, SEO for roofers and SEO for law firms show what that looks like by industry. We have served 400+ clients since 2019, and our case studies show the results.

FAQ

How do I choose an SEO company for my small business?

Ask for the monthly deliverables in writing, check that you own the site and accounts, look for reporting on calls and forms from organic search, and read the exit terms. Rule out anyone who guarantees a ranking.

What should a small business SEO package include?

Keyword research, technical fixes, service and location pages, Google Business Profile work, citations and reviews, and a monthly report tied to leads.

Can an SEO company guarantee first page rankings?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google, and warns against SEOs who claim to.

How long before SEO works for a small business?

SEO compounds over months, not days. Technical fixes and Google Business Profile work can move sooner. Ask each company what it expects, in what timeframe and how it measures it, as Google suggests.

How much do SEO companies charge small businesses?

Most charge a monthly retainer, and the most common band in published surveys is about $500 to $1,000 a month, with many US providers above that. Our guide to SEO cost for a small business has the details.

Talk to us about SEO

If you want a second opinion on a quote, or a scope built for your market, Book a Stride Scaling Call.

Done for you

Want this running in your business?

We build and run AI that answers, follows up and books calls, all reporting into one CRM. Most clients are live in 2 to 3 weeks.

Keep reading

    • SEO
    • Local SEO

    9 min read

    Local SEO for Small Businesses: The Checklist

    Local SEO for small businesses as a checklist: Google Business Profile, categories, a page per service and town, reviews, citations and links, in order.

    Read post
    • SEO
    • Local SEO

    7 min read

    Local SEO Cost: What SEO Costs a Small Business

    Local SEO cost for a small business: monthly, project, hourly and per location pricing, what each buys, and survey ranges from Ahrefs and SE Ranking.

    Read post
    • Real Estate
    • Lead Generation

    8 min read

    Buying Real Estate Leads: Zillow, Portals and Alternatives

    Buying leads for real estate: how Zillow Preferred, Realtor.com, Redfin and Homes.com charge agents, from their own pages, and the own-lead alternatives.

    Read post